La transition tunisienne fracturée/Tunisia's Fractured Transition
Présentation
L'ISJPS organise un séminaire conclusif de ses réflexions sur la transition tunisienne fracturée, en collaboration avec :
- the Arab Center Washington DC
- the Democracy and Governance MA Program
- the Center for Contemporary Arab Studies at Georgetown University.
Ce séminaire se déroulera en anglais.
This open concluding talk will highlight the key questions and insights animating Georgetown University Qatar’s Tunisia Study Group. Made up of scholars and analysts from the US, Iraq, Tunisia, Denmark, Canada, Turkey, Germany, and France, the study group was convened in Spring 2025 to explore the social, economic, political, institutional, and ideological forces that shaped Tunisia’s “Fractured Transition” from 2011 to 2021.
Tunisia’s sudden and unexpected “Revolution of Dignity” in December 2010 triggered political uprisings across the Middle East and North Africa. While most of the countries in the region saw either the reimposition of autocracy or the onset of violent civil conflicts in the years that followed, Tunisia was the only country whose leaders negotiated the terms of a transition to a more competitive democracy.Although Tunisia’s transition was a remarkable achievement, it depended on a power-sharing arrangement between leaders and parties that was meant to diminish domestic conflicts but instead magnified rivalries among them. As elite and societal polarization and fragmentation set in, the wider populace grew profoundly disillusioned with the country’s increasingly ineffective parties and parliament, thus setting the stage for President Kais Saied to shut down parliament and begin reestablishing an autocracy in July 2021.
Tunisia’s experience highlights the challenges of democratic transitions centered on negotiation and power sharing. These challenges stem from a fundamental paradox: while democratic transitions often require new political forces to concede to old regime actors and institutions that want to protect their power, such concessions can undermine further democratization. The tricky task for political leaders is to ensure that a successful operation to exit autocracy what is called a “first transition,” does not kill the democratic patient in the process, thereby ending a second transition to a more robust democracy.
Moving to a second transition can be difficult. Indeed, leaders must often choose between two options. On the one hand, they can sustain a power-sharing arrangement that includes all relevant parties but also gives all members of the governing coalition the means to veto or oppose their rivals’ policies. In practice, this negative consensus hinders major political, economic, and legal reforms, inviting governmental paralysis. On the other hand, leaders can pursue broader reforms that consolidate democracy but might also give rivals the means to impose permanent power, raising fears of what is called “democratic shutout.” Such fears often induce some groups to sabotage further democratic reforms. At its essence, the transition dilemma means choosing between two poor options, the second of which can become especially perilous.
Séminaire organisé par
- Dan Brumberg, professeur de politique comparée au département de science gouvernementale (département de science politique) à l'Université Georgetown, Non-resident Senior Fellow the Arab Center Washington DC
- Xavier Philippe, professeur de droit public et directeur de l'ISJPS
- Zaid Al-Ali, expert constitutionnel indépendant spécialisé dans les pays de la région des pays arabes et du Moyen Orient.
Informations pratiques
Université Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne, centre Lourcine
1 rue de la Glacière, 75013 Paris
Bâtiment 1 Suzanne Bastid, 2e étage, salle 13 (longer le bâtiment puis tourner à droite tout au bout ; pousser la porte en bois pour emprunter l'escalier).
Inscription gratuite mais obligatoire avant vendredi 27 novembre à 10h.
Téléchargez le billet PDF qui vous sera envoyé avec la confirmation de votre inscription : il vous sera indispensable pour entrer dans l'université.
Un document d'identité peut vous être également demandé.